Washington DC\’s Georgetown Cupcake vs. Sprinkles Cupcake

On my recent trip to Washington DC, I made sure to visit Georgetown and check out the two most popular cupcake bakeries; Georgetown Cupcake and Sprinkles.

Georgetown Cupcake was founded by sisters Katherine and Sophie, who also have a series on TLC called DC Cupcakes.  I waited in line for about a half hour before being able to get cupcakes – the cupcakes are $2.75 each.

• The buttercream tasted like cream cheese
• The cupcake was very crumbly and dry
• The \”signature swirl\” looked more like a blob.
I don\’t know if I was at Georgetown Cupcake on an off day or what, but I really do not understand the hype.

Sprinkles was founded by Candace Nelson, who is now also a judge on Food Networks hit series Cupcake Wars. The cupcakes are $3.75 each, and I was able to walk right in and purchase cupcakes.

• The presentation is very chic and aesthetically pleasing. 
• You couldn\’t eat the retro dot on the cupcake – which I didn\’t understand since Candace always complains on the show if there is something non-edible.
• The buttercream was delicious
• The cupcakes were extremely moist

Nail Polish: Zoya Shelby

24 Comments on “Washington DC\’s Georgetown Cupcake vs. Sprinkles Cupcake

  1. you must have hit GC on an off day! because they are usually divine! although the local up cake shop where i live could give them a run or their money!! glad u liked sprinkles!


  2. I love cupcakes! I never had the sprinkles ones but the georgetown ones were good when I tried them but maybe I need to re-test.I really love Baked by Melissa in NYC which are bite sized cupcakes! They pack a lot of flavor and are less than 57(?) cal each.


  3. That's pretty crazy on how the long line = not so great cupcakes and the no line = yummy cupcakes. I use to live in D.C. and never went to either of those places! Although, there is a cupcake place here in Raleigh that is to die for! xoxo A-


  4. I recently had Sprinkles in Chicago and thought they were delicious! And I loved the presentation too- they shop was adorable as well!


  5. I can't believe Georgetown cupcake wasn't good! All the hype! so sad. Those cupcakes at sprinkles look AMAZING!xoxo Jessicawww.mystylevita.com


  6. I've haven't been to Sprinkles yet, and think Georgetown Cupcake is just okay. My fave is Lavender Moon in Alexandria.


  7. I did a face off in Houston between Crave, Celebrity and Sprinkles. Have to say that Celebrity was the best – moist, inventive flavors and good icing. Sprinkles was second. Crave was dry and I couldnt understand the hype. But to be honest, some days a good old fashion supermarket cupcake will do just fine 🙂


  8. Im still searching for the best in Sacramento. At the moment, Cupcake Craving is hitting high marks. Inventive, good fillings, never the same flavors and moist cake – yum!


  9. They both look way cute. I've heard such good things about DC cupcakes. Shame they didnt live up to the hype.


  10. I'm glad you had a great visit! Georgetown cupcake is normally amazing! I'm so sad you didn't have a great experience. I love Crumbs too (and its a lot closer to my office), but I need to get to sprinkles ASAP


  11. i love you for writing such an honest review for georgetown bakery. i have heard so many good things, but i wasn't convinced. you surely know your cupcakes!


  12. I have made Sprinkles cupcakes…you can actually buy the mix at Williams-Sonoma and they come with an edible retro dot (I have no idea why you couldn't eat yours – weird) along with an icing recipe. They were absolutely deelish. 🙂 Hope you had a great time in DC – that is my hometown!!


  13. As a frequent DC cupcaker i completely agree!! Sprinkles is usually #1 with everyone i talk to. We have all had your experience (including myself …numerous times)at gtown cupcakes,so sorry to say its not a fluke. Seriously if you thing gtown cupcakes are good and havnt tried sprinkles yet, you will be amazed.(PS i too was confused about the inedible dot)


  14. The Georgetown Cupcake might have tasted like cream cheese frosting b/c just maybe it was. (most of their cupcakes have cream cheese frosting not butter cream) I love GC and when I had Sprinkles red velvet the other day, I found it very good but the frosting didn't taste enough like cream cheese! The best cupckake for peanut butter and chocolate lovers is BY FAR GC's Peanut Butter Swirl. Of their 3 pb and choco variations, it's the only one with peanut butter in the middle. It is amazzzzingggg!!!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: